Connect with others across the political spectrum

Sign in / Sign up

Texas State Issue

Should Columbus Day be replaced with #Indigenous People's Day in Texas?

Score for this "NO" opinion :
Score is TBD

"Holidays & history lessons shouldn't be filtered" Jul 12, 2024

History is society’s recollection of the past. It is the communal understanding of things that transpired long ago. It is one of the legacies of a nation that defines its identity and uniqueness from other sovereign states. This is why any rewrite or revisions of history should be done with care and respect, not through emotionally charged protests and forceful legislations. 

The issue about Christopher #Columbus and his colonization of America has spurred contention during the past few decades. It is due to the growing sentiment by many people of the apparent wrongdoings of the Italian explorer. Those who are opposed to the continued celebration of Columbus day argue that the United States should not honor a genocidal invader who killed, enslaved, and dispersed millions of native Americans.

The celebration of Columbus Day is not solely focused on the event wherein the navigator reached the new world. Rather, it is a celebration of the beginning of a new world: the Americas who have been pioneers of technology, culture, beliefs, social systems, and morality which developed the modern society today. Though at the onset, the arrival of colonizers in the Americas caused havoc to the new world inhabitants, today the United States of America is now a world leader and example of social rights and justice globally. Many Italian-Americans take pride in Columbus Day to celebrate their heritage. A simple solution would be to celebrate Indigenous Peoples’ Day on a different day, rather than retracting from a holiday which some value for their heritage in favor of another peoples’ heritage.

History may contain stains and blemishes. But in the bigger picture, as we look at the majestic tapestry of humanity, Columbus day marks the start of the American empire: the day when the balance of power, wealth, and influence slowly trickled towards the new world. If not for that fateful day, ushered in by that Italian navigator, America as we know it may well be different. 

However, Columbus can partially be credited with the mere fact we are able to contest history and have the freedom to reject a time-honored holiday because of the freedom of speech guaranteed by the Constitution. Columbus day is a historical event that should be continually celebrated, not because of genocide and slavery, but the good that followed which Americans now casually enjoy.

This website uses cookies
ViewExchange uses cookies to improve performance of the website, to personalize content and advertisements, and to overall provide you with a better experience. By clicking “Accept” or by continuing to use ViewExchange, you accept the use of cookies. You can control your data settings including opting out by clicking here.