Connect with others across the political spectrum

Sign in / Sign up

National & World Issue

Should the government step in to regulate airline "junk fees?" #Airlines


Score for this "No" opinion : 8.8

"The Government Should Not Regulate Airline Fees" Sep 19, 2024

Air travel has become a widely accessible and reasonably priced means to explore the world, connect with others, and engage in business activities. However, the cost of airfare can vary due to factors like destination, season, demand, and airline choice. Among the contentious elements of airfare pricing are the "junk fees," which airlines levy for services and amenities that were once part of the ticket cost. These fees encompass checked baggage, seat selection, priority boarding, in-flight entertainment, meals, and Wi-Fi. Post the COVID-19 pandemic's severe impact on the travel sector, these fees have evolved into a significant income stream for airlines.

In 2019, the U.S. Department of Transportation reported that U.S. airlines amassed $7.1 billion in baggage fees and $2.8 billion in reservation change fees. However, these fees have drawn criticism from consumers, advocacy groups, and legislators who contend they are unjust, misleading, and detrimental to competition. Some advocate for government regulation or capping of these fees, or the requirement for airlines to incorporate them into advertised fares.

Firstly, airline "junk fees" allow carriers to offer lower base fares and more options for consumers. Unbundling services and amenities enables airlines to decrease operational expenses and pass these savings on to customers who prefer to pay solely for their chosen services. This fosters a competitive, varied market where travelers can find flights suiting their budget and preferences. For instance, a traveler seeking just a carry-on bag and not prioritizing seat selection or in-flight entertainment might choose a low-cost carrier with lower ticket prices but additional charges for extras. Conversely, a traveler desiring more comfort and amenities might opt for a full-service carrier with all-inclusive fares at a higher cost. This empowers consumers to tailor their travel experience in line with their needs.

Secondly, "junk fees" reflect actual costs of providing different services, promoting market efficiency and fairness. Charging separately for each service enables airlines to allocate resources more effectively and bill customers accurately for their consumption. This engenders a transparent, equitable pricing model wherein clients pay for what they utilize. For example, checked baggage fees encourage lighter packing, reducing aircraft weight and fuel consumption. Seat selection fees let passengers choose preferred seats based on willingness to pay. In-flight entertainment, meals, and Wi-Fi fees cover installation and maintenance costs. By implementing these fees, airlines can recover expenses and invest in enhancing quality and safety.

Thirdly, these fees are transparent and voluntary, and consumers can avoid them by comparing options. Despite claims of hidden or misleading fees, airlines are legally required to transparently disclose them prior to booking. This information is easily accessible on airline websites or online travel agencies (OTAs), allowing consumers to compare fees across different airlines. Tools like Bing Travel or Kayak aid in identifying deals according to preferences. Additionally, consumers can accept or reject fees based on their value judgment. If a fee seems excessive or unnecessary, they can decline it or select an alternative airline offering a better deal. Thus, consumers can impact the market by voting with their spending choices.

Rather than intervening with the market's forces driving innovation and competition in air travel, the government should honor consumer sovereignty, safeguard consumer rights and safety, and encourage consumer education. By doing so, the government can contribute to an efficient, equitable, and transparent air travel market benefiting all stakeholders.

This website uses cookies
ViewExchange uses cookies to improve performance of the website, to personalize content and advertisements, and to overall provide you with a better experience. By clicking “Accept” or by continuing to use ViewExchange, you accept the use of cookies. You can control your data settings including opting out by clicking here.